Skip to content

/plan mode strips tool set to 4 tools, breaking /fleet and read-only workflows #1820

@Arithmomaniac

Description

@Arithmomaniac

Describe the bug

When a session enters plan mode (/plan or [[PLAN]] prefix), the available tool set drops from ~47 tools to just 4: powershell, report_intent, skill, task. A tools_changed_notice confirms the removal.

File reading still works via powershell and task(explore), and the model can ask clarifying questions via plain text. But the following tools have no workaround:

  • read_agent / list_agents — cannot retrieve results from background agents. /fleet launches agents via task(mode: "background") but their results are silently lost.
  • sql — todo tracking and session store queries fail, despite the system prompt referencing SQL tables and todo status.

Affected version

0.0.421-0

Steps to reproduce the behavior

  1. Start a Copilot CLI session
  2. Have a normal conversation — process log shows tool_count: 47
  3. Enter plan mode via /plan <prompt>
  4. The model receives a tools_changed_notice listing nearly all tools as "no longer available" — only powershell, report_intent, skill, task remain (process log: tool_count: 4)
  5. Use /fleet to launch parallel work
  6. Fleet dispatches background agents via task(mode: "background")
  7. The model tries to call read_agent to retrieve results — tool does not exist
  8. Background agent results that don't leave filesystem artifacts (e.g., investigation-only or API-call agents) are permanently lost

Expected behavior

Plan mode should retain tools that have no workaround:

Tool Why it's needed Workaround?
read_agent, list_agents Retrieve background agent results ❌ None
sql Todo tracking, session store queries ❌ None
ask_user Clarifying questions during planning ⚠️ Degraded — model falls back to plain text questions, but the system prompt explicitly says "use the ask_user tool to confirm assumptions," creating a mismatch between instructions and available tools

Additional context

  • OS: Windows 11 (x86_64), Windows Terminal, PowerShell 7
  • The model generates incorrect self-diagnoses about tool availability (e.g., "read_agent may never have been available") because it only sees the current restricted set.
  • The system prompt still references SQL tables, todo tracking, and ask_user usage, but these tools are unavailable — causing silent failures or instruction-tool mismatches.
  • Related: Feature Request: Plan Mode Tool-Layer Enforcement #1171 requests plan mode to block write tools — this issue is the inverse: read-only tools with no workaround are being blocked.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions